It does look like may apple. Got this from Wikipedia:
Toxicity
The ripened fruit is edible in moderate amounts, though when consumed in large amounts the fruit is poisonous. The rhizome, foliage and roots are also poisonous,[4] Mayapple contains podophyllotoxin,[5] which is used as a...
Wow. I've heard of a goose that lays a golden egg, but never a goat that poops diamonds!
Come to think of it, my DH might actually let me have goats if he thought that was a possibility . . .