I'm glad you two brought this up. Be ready to facepalm my question but....... Why do I need to worry about how to tight the hot wire is? It's giving the same jolt either way right? I do understand if the hot wire is the only thing keeping things in and it. In other words are or 5 line hot wire with no fence.
Depends on what you are trying to keep in (or out) I guess. Wire has a certain amount of 'stretch' to it before it gets tight. Some wire, more than others. HT for instance has virtually no stretch to it, meaning you pull it tight and beyond that, you risk breaking it. Old low carbon steel wire (and the aluminum wire) had a lot of stretch to it...you pulled it tight, then kept pulling until you had all the stretch/elongation out of it. Problem with that was, it was almost impossible to ever get all the elongation out of it and you go back 6 months later and the wire is loose again just because the natural tendency to elongate from temperature changes, weight of the wire between posts and pressure from livestock/widlife.
HT wire doesn't do that, but if you don't tension it good and tight to begin with, it too can suffer from loss of tension due to almost daily changes in temperature..not to mention it looks like crap.. looking like cross section view of swells on an ocean, (peaks and valleys) dipping down between each insulator.
I can drive down the road at normal speed, and just from my truck window tell every fence that was put up using low carbon wire, just from the sag in it, and more than likely, when it was initially installed, it was pulled reasonably tight.
How tight to tension HT wire?
Stop right before the breaking point.

I pull on it till I'm scared to pull even another click on the stretcher..or my arms give out...whichever comes first.