That is a huge debate. I always give mine dry. Some say soak the pellets and not the shredded, some say don't soak either, some say soak both. Some say soak for horses and not for goats. I think that if you are only giving a cup or so at a time they will be fine dry. Look for calf Manna too and only give it to the doe on the milk stand, and just a handful mixed into her other grain. Mine LOVE it but I almost lost a doe when she sneaked into the barn and helped herself to about a quart or more at one time.